VinylAI 
Data as of Sep 25, 2026
Melanie Martinez – Cry Baby
2023 · US · Atlantic · Vinyl LP Album Deluxe Edition Reissue
Be the first to list yours, or get an email the moment a copy appears.
Price guide
Estimated market value via Discogs · as of Sep 25, 2026
- MMint
- $61.80
- NMNear Mint
- $55.29
- VG+Very Good Plus
- $42.28
- VGVery Good
- $29.27
- G+Good Plus
- $16.26
- GGood
- $9.76
- FFair
- $6.51
- PPoor
- $3.25
77 copies listed on Discogs from $7.04.
These are reference estimates from Discogs sold/asking data for this exact pressing, not offers and not a guaranteed price. Actual value depends on condition, completeness and current demand. Any active seller offers on this page are listed separately above.
Offers
New to condition grades like NM or VG? Read our vinyl grading guide →
Pressing identification
Match these against your copy to confirm the exact pressing.
- Barcode
- 075678639494
Specifications
- Artist
- Melanie Martinez
- Genre
- Pop
- Style
- Alt-Pop, Indie Pop, Synth-pop
- Year
- 2023
- Label
- Atlantic
- Catalog number
- 075678639494
- Country
- US
- Barcode
- 075678639494
Tracklist
- A1Cry Baby
- A2Dollhouse
- A3Sippy Cup
- A4Carousel
- A5Alphabet Boy
- B1Soap
- B2Training Wheels
- B3Pity Party
- B4Tag, You're It
- C1Milk And Cookies
- C2Pacify Her
- C3Mrs. Potato Head
- C4Mad Hatter
- D1Play Date
- D2Teddy Bear
- D3Cake
About this record
This 2023 US reissue on Atlantic (catalogue 075678639494) arrives eight years after the original 2015 pressings, making it the first vinyl reissue of Cry Baby as a deluxe edition. The 16-track LP commands a steep condition-based price curve: a Mint copy reaches 61.80 USD while a VG pressing settles at 29.27 USD—a spread that reflects how heavily collectors prize unplayed stock of this synth-pop alt-pop hybrid.
What drives its value
The 2023 reissue sits in a crowded secondary market: 77 copies are listed for sale, yet 3089 collectors own one against only 218 who want it, signaling a glut of available inventory relative to active demand. Price_guide data shows the Mint-to-VG+ range spans from 61.80 USD down to 42.28 USD, with the lowest asking price at 7.04 USD—a floor that reflects heavily played or damaged stock.
The original 2015 US pressings (catalogue 549986-1 and 552518-2) and the European variant (7567-99192-4) have largely been superseded by this reissue in collector priority. Condition dominates value here: even a NM copy at 55.29 USD commands a premium, but once a record dips to VG at 29.27 USD, the resale floor drops sharply.
The community rating of 4.55 across 367 votes confirms the album's artistic appeal, but the want-to-have ratio of 218 to 3089 underscores that supply has caught up with demand.
How to appraise this pressing
Verify this pressing by the barcode 075678639494 on the back cover and the Atlantic label imprint on the vinyl itself. The 2023 reissue status distinguishes it from the four earlier pressings: two US variants from 2015 (549986-1 and 552518-2), one European pressing from 2015 (7567-99192-4), and a 2016 US reissue (549986-1).
The deluxe edition designation and 16-track count confirm you have the correct version. Grade by visual inspection of the vinyl surface and listening test: Mint (M) assumes unplayed condition with no marks; Near Mint (NM) allows only light handling marks; Very Good Plus (VG+) shows light surface noise on quiet passages but no audible groove wear; Very Good (VG) exhibits noticeable surface noise and light scratches visible under light.
The price_guide valuations (M at 61.80 USD through P at 3.25 USD) reflect market estimates as of the guide's publication date and should anchor your appraisal, though actual sales may vary based on pressing plant and dead-wax details not provided in standard listings.
Further reading: grading a record, what makes a pressing valuable.
Listen
Hear the album before you buy.
Official videos via YouTube.
Other pressings of this release
Different editions of the same album — pressing decides value.
Frequently asked
How much is a Mint copy of this 2023 reissue worth?
According to price_guide data, a Mint (M) pressing is valued at 61.80 USD. This represents the highest tier and assumes the record has never been played and shows no signs of handling or storage wear. Actual market prices may differ based on seller reputation and buyer demand at the time of sale.
What is the price difference between a VG+ and a VG copy?
A Very Good Plus (VG+) copy is priced at 42.28 USD, while a Very Good (VG) copy is valued at 29.27 USD according to price_guide. The gap reflects the audible difference: VG+ shows only light surface noise on quiet passages, whereas VG exhibits noticeable surface noise and visible scratches under light.
Why is this 2023 reissue different from the 2015 original pressings?
The 2015 original came in at least three variants: two US pressings (catalogue 549986-1 and 552518-2) and one European pressing (7567-99192-4). This 2023 edition is marketed as a deluxe reissue on Atlantic with catalogue 075678639494 and includes all 16 tracks. A 2016 US reissue also exists under catalogue 549986-1, making the 2023 version the most recent vinyl iteration.
Is this record in high demand?
Demand is moderate relative to supply. The community database shows 218 collectors want it against 3089 who already own one, indicating that copies are readily available. With 77 listings currently for sale and a lowest asking price of 7.04 USD, buyers have ample options, which keeps secondary-market prices competitive.
What does the community rating tell me about this album?
The album holds a 4.55 rating across 367 community votes, suggesting strong artistic reception among collectors. This high rating reflects appreciation for the synth-pop and indie-pop production, though it does not necessarily correlate with rarity or investment potential—the abundance of 3089 owned copies and low want-to-have ratio indicate this is a widely accessible pressing rather than a collectible scarcity.